Riris, P., 2019. Sparse Radiocarbon Data Confound Culture-Climate Links in Late Pre-Columbian Amazonia. Quaternary, 2 (4), 33.
Full text available as:
|
PDF (Open access article)
riris 2019.pdf - Published Version Available under License Creative Commons Attribution. 1MB | |
Copyright to original material in this document is with the original owner(s). Access to this content through BURO is granted on condition that you use it only for research, scholarly or other non-commercial purposes. If you wish to use it for any other purposes, you must contact BU via BURO@bournemouth.ac.uk. Any third party copyright material in this document remains the property of its respective owner(s). BU grants no licence for further use of that third party material. |
Official URL: https://www.mdpi.com/2571-550X/2/4/33
DOI: 10.3390/quat2040033
Abstract
It has recently been argued that pre-Columbian societies in the greater Amazon basin during the Late Holocene were subject to “adaptive cycling”. In this model, cultures practicing “intensive” land use practices, such as raised field agriculture, were vulnerable to perturbations in hydroclimate, whereas “extensive” land use patterns, such as polyculture agroforestry, are viewed as more resilient to climate change. On the basis of radiocarbon data, the relative rise and fall of late pre-Columbian cultures and their inferred patterns of land use in six regions are highlighted to exemplify this model. This paper re-examines the radiocarbon evidence marshalled in favour of adaptive cycling, demonstrating that alleged temporal patterning in these data are overwhelmingly likely due to a combination of sampling effects, lack of statistical controls, and unacknowledged uncertainties that are inherent to radiocarbon dating. The outcome of this combination of factors seriously limits the possibility of cross-referencing archaeological data with palaeo-ecological and -climatological data without controlling for these effects, undermining the central archaeological pillar in support of adaptive cycling in Amazonia. This paper illustrates examples of such mitigation measures and provides the code to replicate them. Suggestions for how to overcome the serious limitations identified in the Late Holocene radiocarbon record of Amazonia are presented in the context of ongoing debates on inferring climatic causation in archaeological and historical datasets.
Item Type: | Article |
---|---|
ISSN: | 2571-550X |
Additional Information: | climate change; resilience; Amazonia; radiocarbon dating; archaeology |
Group: | Faculty of Science & Technology |
ID Code: | 33464 |
Deposited By: | Symplectic RT2 |
Deposited On: | 20 Feb 2020 15:56 |
Last Modified: | 14 Mar 2022 14:20 |
Downloads
Downloads per month over past year
Repository Staff Only - |